CHRIST IN WINTER: The
Irrelevant Reminiscences of An Old Preacher:
“The first shall be last, and the last shall be first.” [Mt 20:16] [1]
The first time I heard a preacher circle back and end the sermon in the same place where it started was in chapel when I was a seminary student. The preacher was the renowned George Buttrick, who had moved to Chicago in his retirement, because he was a Cubs fan. Since he was there anyway, when Garrett Theological Seminary, at Northwestern U, asked him to teach a course in New Testament Preaching, he agreed. That meant he was occasionally asked to preach in chapel. Nobody missed chapel when George Buttrick preached.
He started that sermon with an episode from a current novel. The story ended with the character standing on a balcony, looking at the scene below. Buttrick continued, in ways that would drive a homiletics prof mad.
He never looked at the congregation. His eyes wandered all over, looking out the window, up at the ceiling, into the distance. He seemed to be trying to figure out what to say next, yet every word followed the one before with precision. His inflection was monotonal. He never yelled. Never whispered. Just kept talking, as if it didn’t matter if anyone else heard. He didn’t gesture, just held to the sides of the pulpit, as though he would fall down otherwise.
There was no other sound in that chapel. Every eye and every ear was attuned to the wistful-sounding figure in the pulpit, because every word he spoke took that novel character off his balcony and into life. We couldn’t wait to see where he went next.
Where he went finally was back to the beginning. Still standing on the balcony, but seeing the scene below with in entirely new ways, with entirely new eyes.
I was delighted, in part because his style was the one that came naturally to me. I never gestured, or shouted, or whispered. All that seemed false to me. Not necessarily for other preachers, but certainly for me. As a friend once said, “You just stand there and talk.” I never did know if he meant it as a compliment or insult. But I figured if it were okay for George Buttrick to do it, it was okay for me.
Where I differed from Buttrick was in looking at the congregation. I did not know where to take that character from the balcony until I learned from looking at the folks in front of me where they needed him to go.
I always harked back to my very first Sunday preaching, on the Chrisney circuit. I preached three times that morning, first at Crossroads, then at Chrisney, then at Bloomfeld. The same sermon in each place. Except it wasn’t. It was three different sermons, because each congregation made the same sermon theirs alone, just by the way they listened.
I think Buttrick saw the congregation without looking at it. I was not able to do that. But I learned to start and end my sermons in the same place. [2]
The gospel is a circle. It ends and starts at the same place. “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God and the Word was God…” [John 1:1] Easter is just circling back to Christmas, Emmanuel, God with us.
John Robert McFarland
1] Yes, Bible scholars, I know this is out of context.
2] I was not at all
surprised when Margaret Moos, the producer of Garrison Keillor’s Prairie
Home Companion radio show, asked me to write for the show, because Keillor
and I think alike. He is the master at circling his monologues back to their
beginning, with delightful results.
.jpg)





