CHRIST IN WINTER: The Irrelevant Musings of An Old Questioner—
“No shirt, No shoes, No service.” “We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone.”
“No service” seems to be trending these days. “At his request, there will be no service.”
“Please don’t talk about me when I’m gone.” [1]
Jesus didn’t have a funeral, so maybe the folks who demand that we not talk about them when they’re gone are just trying to be like Jesus.
Jesus knew he was going to die. Had a pretty good idea when it would be. He didn’t say anything about a funeral service, though.
He did say, however, that we should talk about him after he was gone, every time we broke bread together.
Some folks sort of tried for a service for him. I mean, they used herbs and spices on his body, the customs of the day. A kindly man loaned his tomb. But that wasn’t really a funeral or burial. No crowd at the funeral home. No graveside service. No taped version of “Peace In the Valley.” Was it because Jesus knew he’d be resurrected, so a funeral was irrelevant?
My great, late friend, Jack Newsome, died during covid days. His wife said there would be a funeral later. But then she moved to California to live with a daughter. Then she died. No one to organize a funeral for Jack, which was very sad, for there were so many good stories to tell about Jack. So I decided to organize an online funeral for him, among his still-living friends. We emailed “Jack” stories back and forth. It was nice. It wasn’t adequate.
We knew Scott as a coffee shop owner, but he had once been a seminarian and student pastor. The day after Thanksgiving, a woman from his church came to see him. She told him that the day before, the whole family had gathered at her mother’s for a big Thanksgiving meal, as they always did. The food was on the table, everyone was seated, Grandma brought in the turkey, took her place at the end of the table, took a gun out of her apron pocket, put it in her mouth, and blew her brains out.
Was that a way of requesting no funeral service? Certainly no one would want to talk about it in public, the way we do at memorial services. “Remember the time that Grandma…”
Well, it was about having control, right up to the very last moment…and after, because who is going to forget a scene like that?
Most folks aren’t quite that controlling, but there are those who still want to have the last word, even when they’re dead.
Are they afraid of what people will say at a service, afraid they will be embarrassed? Or are they so humble they just want to save folks the trouble?
Anyway, Scott realized he had nothing to say to that woman. He knew right then, he said, that he was cut out to be a coffee shop guy, not a pastor.
I understand. I’ve done some funerals in those kinds of situations.
But isn’t the funeral for the survivors? Why do you even care? You won’t be there. It will make no diff to you.
And why stop there? If you are so eager to control everything that you say no service, why don’t you just go ahead and tell your loved ones that after you’re dead, no movie, no Florida vacation, no pickleball, no jalapenos?
I enjoyed thinking about my funeral when I thought I would die at 55--what songs folks would sing, what they would say. Not so much now that I’m so old that nobody will be there, since all my friends are either dead or unable to travel.
Maybe Jesus knew he would be resurrected so a funeral was irrelevant. Maybe those folks who say “no funeral for me” are just resurrection believers.
Anyway, if you’re thinking about telling folks, no services for me, think about it some more…and if you care about those you leave behind, remember why we say GOOD GRIEF! rather than NO GRIEF!
John Robert McFarland
1]. Sam H. Stept and
Sydney Clare wrote it in 1930. Ethel Waters sang it first, in 1931.







