CHRIST IN WINTER:
Reflections on Faith & Life for the Years of Winter— Don’t Talk About Me When I’m Gone… [M, 2-13-23]
“Please don’t talk about
me when I’m gone…” That’s a Sidney Clare song lyric from 1930. These days,
folks aren’t saying “Please.”
I check the obituaries in
several newspapers online. Increasingly, they contain a line like this,
“According to the wishes of [name of deceased], there will be no funeral or
memorial services.”
Why does [name of the
deceased] get to decide that? The service is not for [name of the deceased].
It’s for the survivors. They should get to decide that.
And how nasty is that,
anyway? I’m going to decide what you kids and grandkids and parents and
siblings and friends can do even after I’m dead!
It reminds me of why my
friend, Scott, left the ministry and became a coffee shop owner.
“The day after
Thanksgiving, a woman came to see me. She said that on Thanksgiving Day, the
family had gathered at her mother’s, as always. Her mother had cooked a big
meal, as always. Everybody was seated at the table. Her mother brought in the
turkey, put it on the table, sat down at her place, pulled a pistol out of her
apron pocket, put it to her head and killed herself.”
Scott said, “I had nothing
at all to say to her. I knew I was in the wrong profession.”
Well, I was in that
profession for about a hundred years, and I wouldn’t have anything to say to
her, either. Nobody would. Oh, a psychiatrist or psychologist, or even a
preacher, could put a name to what she did, and catalog the ostensible reasons
that she did it, but that is no help to a person who is going to live with that
image and all its possible meanings for the rest of their life.
Doing something like that?
To your whole family? I don’t think there are any words adequate to describe
that kind of desperation, aggression, hate, sadness, loneliness, nastiness,
sinfulness…all mixed up together.
I wonder about that
woman’s funeral, and the person who conducted it. I’ve done a lot of difficult
funerals, but never for someone who was so intentionally unkind to all who
would be gathered there for that service.
There are a lot of
preacher jokes about that sort of thing. They never reflect well on the
preacher. Like the woman who wanted the preacher to do a funeral for her cat.
He refused. She offered a thousand dollars. He said, “Well, you did say that
cat was a Methodist, right?” Or the preacher who didn’t want to do a funeral
for a man who was too nasty to think of anything good to say about him. They
offered a thousand bucks. So she did it, but the best she could come up with
was, “Well, at least he wasn’t as bad as his brother.”
[Back when I first heard
these stories, it was only $100, but that’s not enough anymore to make the joke
work.]
Back to the original
intent of this column… the deceased being the one to decide on whether they
should have a memorial service… no, and it’s not just because I want the
thousand bucks for doing the service.
I’m sure someone will say,
“Well, they never let me make decisions when I was alive, so finally I get to
make one.” No! If you couldn’t stand up and tell folks that you were a real
person without blowing your brains out at the Thanksgiving table, or demanding
no memorial service, you forfeited your God-given right to be a person. Christ
died so you can be a real person. This is your final chance, not to say “No,”
but to say, “I am a person because God made me and Christ died for me. The rest
of this stuff doesn’t matter. Let ‘em talk about me anyway when they want when
I’m gone.”
John Robert McFarland